Europäische Sprachkritik Online (ESO)
EN

European language criticism

Linguistic purism and language criticism

Vol. 3 · 2018

European · Comparative article

Linguistic purism and language criticism in European perspective

Sybille Große, Yohanna Mebrahtu, Ruth Möhlig-Falke

This article examines the postulate of the ‘purity’ of language, which was previously presented for the different language cultures individually, comparatively in diachronic and synchronic perspective, correlating the different traits. ›Linguistic purism‹ is hereby seen as both criticism of language use and criticism of forms and structures of a language. The comparative article illustrates in which constellations of languages linguistic purism was relevant in the past and still is today and how the individual languages were and are affected by language-puristic activities. Finally, the article will compare the actors and specific discursive connections between the different language cultures.

Cite

Große, Sybille / Mebrahtu, Yohanna / Möhlig-Falke, Ruth (2018): Linguistic purism and language criticism in European perspective. In: Handbuch Europäische Sprachkritik Online (HESO), Vol. 3. DOI: 10.17885/heiup.heso.2018.0.23880

Articles on individual languages

Vol. 3 · 2018

Individual language · German

Linguistic purism and language criticism in German

Horst Schwinn, Yohanna Mebrahtu, Ruth Möhlig-Falke

Abstract

Linguistic purism is a form of language criticism. Its primary objective is to ‘keep the language pure’. Keeping the language pure first of all refers to the rejection of foreign-language influences, especially in lexis, but attempts to develop a norm as well as the advancement of a standard or national language are also part of linguistic purism. Linguistic purism can be promoted by individuals as well as by institutions. First attempts at trying to keep the German language pure date back to language societies in the 17th century. From a diachronic perspective, purism has focused on different aspects of language and its usage. What all puristic efforts have in common is that they are usually linked to a rise in national sentiment. Despite institutional efforts – and contrary to other languages – purism is not part of the German language policy and thus not government-controlled.

Cite

Schwinn, Horst / Mebrahtu, Yohanna / Möhlig-Falke, Ruth (2018): Linguistic purism and language criticism in German. In: Handbuch Europäische Sprachkritik Online (HESO), Vol. 3. DOI: 10.17885/heiup.heso.2018.0.23885

Vol. 3 · 2018

Individual language · English

Linguistic purism and language criticism in English

Beatrix Busse, Ruth Möhlig-Falke, Bryan Vit, Beatrix Busse, Ruth Möhlig-Falke, Bryan Vit

Abstract

Linguistic purism refers to an activity which aims at cleansing a language from unwanted influences. However, what counts as an ‘unwanted influence’ usually rests on certain social ideals that are not necessarily shared by all members of a society. These ideals may be oriented towards a nostalgic conception of the past, towards certain ethnographic varieties, or towards the language usage of a conceived social elite. This article gives an overview of different language-purifying attempts made with respect to British English in the course of its history. In comparison with other languages, it is remarkable that purifying efforts have never exerted any larger or longer-lasting influence on the English language, despite or because of the diverse situations of language contact that it was involved in.

Cite

Busse, Beatrix / Möhlig-Falke, Ruth / Vit, Bryan / Busse, Beatrix / Möhlig-Falke, Ruth / Vit, Bryan (2018): Linguistic purism and language criticism in English. In: Handbuch Europäische Sprachkritik Online (HESO), Vol. 3. DOI: 10.17885/heiup.heso.2018.0.23890

Vol. 3 · 2018

Individual language · French

Linguistic purism and language criticism in French

Johannes Funk, Verena Weiland, Kathrin Wenz

Abstract

This abstract and article are only available in German and French.

Cite

Funk, Johannes / Weiland, Verena / Wenz, Kathrin (2018): Linguistic purism and language criticism in French. In: Handbuch Europäische Sprachkritik Online (HESO), Vol. 3. DOI: 10.17885/heiup.heso.2018.0.23891

Vol. 3 · 2018

Individual language · Italian

Linguistic purism and language criticism in Italian

Luisa Larsen, Elisa Manca, Nelson Puccio, Till Stellino

Abstract

This abstract and article are only available in German and Italian.

Cite

Larsen, Luisa / Manca, Elisa / Puccio, Nelson / Stellino, Till (2018): Linguistic purism and language criticism in Italian. In: Handbuch Europäische Sprachkritik Online (HESO), Vol. 3. DOI: 10.17885/heiup.heso.2018.0.23893

Vol. 3 · 2018

Individual language · Croatian

Linguistic purism and language criticism in Croatian

Jadranka Gvozdanović, Iva Petrak

Abstract

This abstract and article are only available in German and Croatian.

Cite

Gvozdanović, Jadranka / Petrak, Iva (2018): Linguistic purism and language criticism in Croatian. In: Handbuch Europäische Sprachkritik Online (HESO), Vol. 3. DOI: 10.17885/heiup.heso.2018.0.23895

Cooperation partners